When exposure is mentioned on Charmed, it is usually referring to human society discovering the existence of magic. This was something which all supernatural forces—both good and evil—had to avoid at all costs, given that there are highly dangerous consequences should mortals discover that magic is real.^[1] A testament to this would be how one such exposure set off a series of events that ultimately led to the tragic, irreversible death of Prue Halliwell, the oldest Charmed One, which in turn broke the Power of Three altogether.^[2] Though the Power of Three was later reconstituted by the revelation of the youngest Charmed One, Paige Matthews, it was still a lesson that had a dramatic impact on the rest of the show and on the sisters' lives, one that they especially took to heart, given that the cost was so dear: the loss of a sister.^[3]

History

Alternative History

In an Alternative Reality where Prue is alive, magic and witches are exposed by Phoebe Halliwell who used her powers to kill Cal Greene. This act of murder caused the reignition of Witch Trials and various people were falsely accused of witchcraft and burned alive in modern versions of stakes.^[4]

The First Exposure

Main article: Exposure of Magic and Prue Halliwell's Death

Magic is exposed for the first time by Elana Dominguez when she accidentally taped Piper and Prue vanquishing the demon assassin Shax. Her superiors didn't take it seriously, thinking it to be publicity made by the military, but they allowed her to try to find out if it was really something supernatural.^[5]

When the demon attacked in the open again, the sisters were forced to vanquish him in public, proving that it was really supernatural. Media and crazy people surrounded the manor and Piper was shot by an unstable witch practitioner, resulting in her death. Desperate to save Piper, Prue used telekinesis to scare people away and again to keep the military from barging into the operating room. Fortunately Leo, Phoebe, and Cole made it to convince the Source of All Evil to force Tempus to reverse time, though Prue died.

Wyatt Halliwell's Accidental Exposure

Wyatt Halliwell whose powers were well developed already at infancy, conjured from a TV show a dragon who was set loose on San Francisco, thereby exposing magic to the mortal world. This act caused the Cleaners, magical beings created by the Tribunal to prevent exposure, to attempt removing Wyatt from reality, though the interference of the Charmed Ones prevented it.^[6]

Dark Future

In an alternative future an evil version of Wyatt exposed magic and took over both the Underworld and the mortal realm. In this future San Francisco laid in ruins, the manor was turned into a memorial museum and demons roamed free.^[7] This future, however, was averted.^[8]

The Ultimate Exposure

A Darklighter named Rennek, caused, through unknown means, for magic to switch sides on the Earthly plane. All magical beings on the Earthly plane at the time of the switch lost their powers and mortals gained magic, thereby exposing magic to the world. With the Earth cut off from those who enforce the magical rules (such as the Elders and the Angels of Destiny), mortals use magic to their Personal Gain and amusement. Meanwhile the government tries to track the source of magic and create Magic Squads to capture those who doesn't exhibit signs of supernatural abilities.^[9]

Tuatha's Havoc

Evil witch Tuatha was able to resurrect herself by possessing Tyler Michaels, a powerful being known as an Archai. She tried to escape the Charmed Ones through a fire portal, but Prue was able to force her out into the neighborhood. A battle then commenced with Tuatha opening several portals that allowed demons to come through, which exposed magic. After Tuatha was defeated and the demons eradicated, the Cleaners were called in to erase all onlookers' memories.^[10]

Precautions to prevent Exposure

The Cleaners are primarily responsible for keeping magic concealed from the mortal world. Employed by the Tribunal, the Cleaners are a neutral party who are willing to erase other beings existence and even let them die unfairly to prevent magic from being exposed.

The Libris, while not interested in preventing the exposure of magic, are bent on keeping the existence of demons hidden. In fact, the very reason why demon's bodies tend to combust and disintegrate upon death is to cover their tracks from mortals.

Secret Keepers

While the existence of magic must remain secret, a number of mortals have been aware of its existence and agreed to protect it from the rest of the world.

• Andy Trudeau
• Darryl Morris
• Victor Bennett
• Bane Jessup
• Henry Mitchell
• Glen Belland
• Jessica
• Sheila Morris
• Agent Murphy
• Mylie
• Craig Wilson
• Harriet Casey
• Elise Rothman
• Gordan Franklin
• Alexandra van Lewen
• Darcy
• Jason Dean
• Kyle Gwydion
• Tanya Parker
• Inspector Cortez
• Mr. and Mrs. Michaels

Notable Occurrences

• 2009, Alternative Future: Phoebe exposed magic and brought back the Witch Trials by killing Cal Greene with her powers. This timeline was erased.
• 2001: The world discovered magic because Prue and Piper were filmed vanquishing Shax. Tempus later reversed time.
• 2003: The sisters expose magic to lure out the Cleaners in an attempt to get Wyatt back, who had previously conjured a Dragon. The Cleaners erased the exposure.
• 2026, Alternative Future: Future Wyatt turned evil caused by the Elder Gideon and exposed magic to the world while ruling over San Francisco. This future was altered.
• 2009: Magic switches sides and mortals, now with powers at their disposal, use them to their gain. Meanwhile, the government creates squads to track the source of magic. Balance was eventually restored and mortals forgot the times they had powers.
• 2010: Tuatha opened several portals in a neighborhood in San Francisco, allowing multiple demons to emerge. After the witch was vanquished, the Cleaners erased the witnesses' memory.

Exception

• The Speakeasy: Magic was openly used at the speakeasy that was ran by P. Baxter and her husband during the 1920s—P. Russell was known for her talents in potion brewing and divination, and she and her cousins (P. Baxter and P. Bowen) openly used their active powers in a fight. Hence, it could be theorised that the speakeasy also functioned as a sort of getaway for witches, given that there was no mention of Baxter and Bowen incurring any dramatic negative consequences for their open usage of magical powers.

Notes and Trivia

• In "Love Hurts", Alec shoots an arrow of his crossbow against Leo during daylight in the middle of an urban street and Leo orbs away seconds later, without anyone noticing. Whitelighters orbing in plain sight will be repeated in later episodes as well.
• The sudden appearance of the Cleaners in Season 6 is a subject of much debate and controversy in the fandom. Many fans feel their existence create plotholes surrounding the exposure in earlier episodes, most notably "All Hell Breaks Loose"; however, since past occurrences where magic faced exposure were dealt with by the sisters on their own, it may be that the Cleaners only step in when they know they are needed, allowing the witches and demons to keep the secret themselves most of the time.

References